BN328 EA, BN323 EA and BN430

Someting stupid happened to my forward test using Bonansa EA. I just check my vps, usually I have 11 metatrader and 29 EA running on my vps. When I check, all 3 meta trader used for testing BN328 EA (EUR/USD), BN323 EA (USD/JPY) and BN430 EA (EUR/JPY) is missing. I think I close it by mistake LOL.

More stupid is, on 7 July 2008 I see my memory in the vps is increasing, so I add new EA for test. The increasing memory because the closure of Bonansa EA LOL. Now my memory in the vps is full so I can't test Bonansa EA anymore.

And here is the last test of Bonansa EA using FXOPEN and last trade was on 4 June 2008 only three days from last Bonansa post.

Here is BN328 EA for EUR/USD result dated 15 July 2008 and can download the statement here


Here is BN323 EA for USD/JPY result dated 15 July 2008 and can download the statement here


Here is BN430 EA for EUR/JPY result dated 15 July 2008 and can download the statement here


Overall Bonansa is profitable in long term, although the Risk Ratio is 1:12 which I think is high, but from the backtest give more than 90% winning percentage.
If in your 1st day live with Bonansa EA and get SL, than u are unlucky, because need 12 winning trade to cover the loss.
In using scalping EA, different broker give different result. Bonansa recommended using ODL Broker for this EA. May the pips with u all.

BN328 EA and BN323 EA Looking Good

My forward test on BN328 EA for EUR/USD pair and BN323 EA for USD/JPY pair already one month now. The result is promising.

I also start to test BN430 EA for EUR/JPY on July but it's not a good start

Here is BN328 EA for EUR/USD result dated 01 July 2008 and can download the statement here


Here is BN323 EA for USD/JPY result dated 01 July 2008 and can download the statement here


Here is BN430 EA for EUR/JPY result dated 01 July 2008 and can download the statement here

BN328 EA and BN323 EA Result

In My previous post, I confuse about the time entry so I make forward test using FXDD and FXOPEN. Bonansa already confirm to me that the start time is 19:00 GMT.

FXDD and FXOPEN is GMT+3 now because of DST.
In my previous post, I test in FXDD set time = 23 and FXOPEN set time = 22. So the correct one is FXOPEN demo which is set time = 22

The result is quite good so far.
Here is BN328 EA for EU result dated 18 June 2008 and can download the statement here


Here is BN323 EA for UJ result dated 18 June 2008 and can download the statement here


And When u compare with live statement provided by the author using ODL broker.

BN328 EA for EUR/USD in FXOPEN loss 2 times since 22 May 2008. It's on 10 May 2008 and 11 May 2008 while in ODL just 1 loss on 12 May 2008.
I still keep test Bonansa EA on FXDD and give 3 loss. It's on 10, 11 and 12 May 2008
It seems different price data feed from broker give different result.

BN323 EA for USD/JPY in FXOPEN give same result with ODL, just one loss so far on 22 May 2008.

It seems BN323 EA for USD/JPY pair is better so far. IF anyone have test it using different broker, fell free to give comment.

BN328 EA, BN323 EA, BN430EA

I found a good scalping EA. It's Japanese EA. The creator is Bonansa so I called it Bonansa EA. He release 2 EA called BN328 EA for EUR/USD and BN323 EA for USD/JPY. But now he already release BN430 EA for EUR/JPY

The backtest result is impressive, more than 95% chance of winning since 1999 until 2008. It's better than Shark EA backtest result. You can see it in his official website Bonansa EA. You can also see live statement provided by the author.

I request a demo for BN328 EA and BN323 EA.
One think you should know about the EA is the risk ratio. Default TP 5 SL 60 and this EA is run on certain time only. So time setting is very important.

Here I quote what he said on email:
BN328 should open positions 4:00-6:59 now in Tokyo. So that you should set the parameter "EntryHour" to 22 at FXDD during its summer time.
After the summer time, you should change "EntryHour" to 23.
So BN328 will open positions 5:00-7:59 after the summer time.

But one think bother me is Tokyo use no DST, So Tokyo time should always the same GMT+9. Time change is broker server time and market trading time. But according to the author, EA open on 4:00-6:59(GMT+9) during DST and 5:00-7:59 (GMT+9) non DST. So it's confuse me.

So I decide to make two forward test since 19 May 2008

I'm using FXOPEN with time setting recommend by the author "4:00-6:59(GMT+9) during DST and 5:00-7:59 (GMT+9) non DST"

Here is BN328 EA for EU result dated 6 June 2008 and can download the statement here


Here is BN323 EA for UJ result dated 6 June 2008 and can download the statement here


I also test it using FXDD with different time setting. I base on GMT about the setting because Tokyo time never change.
FXDD= 23 during DST (GMT+3) so it's 5:00 on Tokyo time (GMT+9)
FXDD= 22 during non DST (GMT+2) so it's 5:00 on Tokyo time (GMT+9)

Here is BN328 EA for EU result dated 6 June 2008 and can download the statement here


Here is BN323 EA for UJ result dated 6 June 2008 and can download the statement here


As you can see different time make different result. So i want to test it little longer before decide to buy it.

About BN430 EA. I'll request the demo version and post the result in here too.

EDIT: I get reply from Bonansa about time setting
"I've tested my EAs on ODL, which is GMT+0 throughout the year, so we don't have to change EntryHour on GMT. Please set the EA to open the position at 19:00 GMT, which mean 4:00 (GMT+9), throughout the year"

It's clear now. Default set time should be 19:00 GMT or 4:00 (GMT+9). So if your broker server time is GMT +3 should be set 22. Remember DST changes by certain broker. Next time I will just continue forward test on FXOPEN, because it follow the correct time rule.